The April Creepy Crate is now open! Subscribe by April 10. 

Collection: Mysterious Gifts

Searching for gifts for your personal Agatha Christie? Have a pal who can't get enough murder mysteries to satisfy their sleuthing needs? Our best mystery-themed gifts are sure to solve this riddle.
4 products
  • 4-Item Mystery Grab Bag
    Regular price
    $20.00
    Sale price
    $20.00
  • 5-Item Mystery Grab Bag
    Regular price
    $25.00
    Sale price
    $25.00
  • Creepy Crate Subscription
    Regular price
    $39.99
    Sale price
    $39.99
  • Vincent Price Mini-Bust [LIMITED EDITION]
    Regular price
    $19.95
    Sale price
    $19.95