Skip to content
Submit
Close search
The SEPTEMBER Crate is now open! Orders close in
SUBSCRIBE NOW
UNBOXING VIDEOS
SHOP CREEPY STORE
SHOP ALL
BEST SELLERS
HORROR
TRUE CRIME
ACCESSORIES
GAMES
KITCHEN/HOME
STATIONERY
FAQ
Privacy Policy
Submit
Search
Log in
Cart
SUBSCRIBE NOW
UNBOXING VIDEOS
SHOP CREEPY STORE
SHOP CREEPY STORE Menu
SHOP CREEPY STORE
SHOP ALL
BEST SELLERS
HORROR
TRUE CRIME
ACCESSORIES
GAMES
KITCHEN/HOME
STATIONERY
FAQ
Privacy Policy
Collection:
Products
Filter by
All products
Bestseller
Games
Valentine
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
choosing a selection results in a full page refresh
44 products
"I'd Rather Be Watching True Crime" Shirt
"I'd Rather Be Watching True Crime" Shirt
Regular price
$20.00
Sale price
$20.00
Sale
'The Scariest Books You've Ever Read' Bookmark
'The Scariest Books You've Ever Read' Bookmark
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Baphomet Mug
Baphomet Mug
Regular price
$15.00
Sale price
$15.00
Sale
Book Brooch
Book Brooch
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Camp Arawak Drawstring Bag
Camp Arawak Drawstring Bag
Regular price
$10.00
Sale price
$10.00
Sale
Cask of Skulls Tea Infuser
Cask of Skulls Tea Infuser
Regular price
$12.00
Sale price
$12.00
Sale
Check the Backseat Air Freshener
Check the Backseat Air Freshener
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Chucky Beach Ball
Chucky Beach Ball
Regular price
$15.00
Sale price
$15.00
Sale
Coffee Bat Pin
Coffee Bat Pin
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Creepy Crate Subscription
Creepy Crate Subscription
Regular price
$39.99
Sale price
$39.99
Sale
Creepy Crate Subscription Gift Card
Creepy Crate Subscription Gift Card
Regular price
$0.00
Sale price
$0.00
Sale
Creepy Valentine Set (Instant Download)
Creepy Valentine Set (Instant Download)
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Creepy Valentines (Instant Download)
Creepy Valentines (Instant Download)
Regular price
$3.00
Sale price
$3.00
Sale
Cthulhu Sticker
Cthulhu Sticker
Regular price
$4.00
Sale price
$4.00
Sale
Free the West Memphis Three Patch
Free the West Memphis Three Patch
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Gingerdead Man Cookie Cutter
Gingerdead Man Cookie Cutter
Regular price
$10.00
Sale price
$10.00
Sale
Goody Proctor T-Shirt
Goody Proctor T-Shirt
Regular price
$20.00
Sale price
$20.00
Sale
Hurricane Cup
Hurricane Cup
Regular price
$20.00
Sale price
$20.00
Sale
I ❤️ Derry T-shirt
I ❤️ Derry T-shirt
Regular price
$20.00
Sale price
$20.00
Sale
Krampus Pin
Krampus Pin
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Manson Travel Mug
Manson Travel Mug
Regular price
$15.00
Sale price
$15.00
Sale
Pieces Puzzle
Pieces Puzzle
Regular price
$15.00
Sale price
$15.00
Sale
Pope Lick Monster Lollipop
Pope Lick Monster Lollipop
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Pumpkin Pin
Pumpkin Pin
Regular price
$8.00
Sale price
$8.00
Sale
Previous page
Page 1 of 2
Next page
